- I'm on the fence about value. Out of four boxes, there were probably two hits worth writing home about, the Gwynn and the Fingers. The Thome is nice, as is the Rollins, but the base Ultimate Star Materials cards are bland, and there are way too many average players and not enough stars for a product of this price point. I'd give this product a 6/10 for value.
- I like the designs for the America's Pastime autos and relics. It would be nice to know what the print runs were for this. Overall, the designs are beautiful, with good texture, color, print quality, stock, and design. I'd give this a 8/10 for design.
- Quality. Hmm, I think that most of the cards are high-quality, but I must say that if you look closely at the right-hand patch on the Gwynn, it is mis-registered and you can see past the swatch to the inside of the card. Not great. It's still a magnificent card, though, and anybody would be lucky to have it. More care could have been taken, too, to align the stickers on some of the auto cards. Quality gets a 7/10.
Overall, I think this deserves a 7/10. What do you think?